City or town · Market Pulse
Last 5 years: November 1, 2025 to October 31, 2026. 408 homes sold.
Strong seller's market
Based on plenty of sales. Ratings describe market conditions in this area, not any one home, and aren't a recommendation to buy or sell.
Castro Valley's market over the past five years has seen modest price growth alongside a significant shift in supply and demand dynamics. The median sale price rose 4.6% to $1,133,324, with per-square-foot pricing up 6.6%, but the pace of sales has slowed dramatically. Homes sold dropped 42.3% and pending sales fell 41.0% compared to five years ago, while inventory nearly doubled and months of supply grew from 0.5 to 1.6. Homes are now staying on the market longer, taking 15 days on average versus 8 days five years earlier, and far fewer are selling above list price, down from 85.6% to 60.6%.
For sellers: Sellers still have conditions in their favor, with homes selling for 103.7% of list price on average and 60.6% going above asking, but the advantage has weakened significantly. Homes are taking longer to attract offers and face more downward pressure than they did five years ago, when bidding wars were more common.
For buyers: Buyers have considerably more choice and negotiating power than five years ago, with inventory up 97% and months of supply at 1.6, though options remain limited historically. Competition has eased substantially, with less than half of homes going under contract within two weeks, compared to 74.9% five years earlier.
Over this span the median sale price grew about 0.9% a year.
Median sale price
$1,133,324
+4.6% vs 5 years earlier
Price per sq ft
$670
+6.6% vs 5 years earlier
Homes sold
408
−42.3% vs 5 years earlier
Sale-to-list
103.7%
−6.8 pts vs 5 years earlier
Sold above list
61%
−25.0 pts vs 5 years earlier
Median days on market
15 days
+7 days vs 5 years earlier
Months of supply
1.6
+1.1 mo vs 5 years earlier
New listings
462
−33.8% vs 5 years earlier
Each point covers the 3 months ending that month.
Above 100% means homes are selling over asking on average.
New listings coming on vs. homes selling, with months of supply.
Median days on market, and the share going under contract within two weeks.
Inventory at the end of each period.
Sales by calendar month across every year of data (100 = an average month).
Zillow Research data through October 2026. A separate source from the Redfin numbers above, so the figures won't match exactly.
Zillow Home Value Index
+1.5% vs 5 years earlier (+0.3%/yr)
Typical rent (ZORI)
+8.1% vs a year earlier
Gross rental yield
Annual rent ÷ home value, before costs
Listings with a price cut
−0.2 pts vs a year earlier
Median days to pending
Zillow Home Value Index (left) and Observed Rent Index (right).
Share of listings with a price cut (left) and median days to pending (right).
Source: Zillow Research. The Market Heat Index runs 0 to 100: 70 and up is a strong seller's market, 28 and under a strong buyer's market.